| Vendor | Smartsheet Inc. (Brandfolder by Smartsheet) | Frontify AG |
|---|
| HQ | USA (Brandfolder founded in Denver, CO; parent Smartsheet in Bellevue, WA) | Switzerland (St. Gallen) |
|---|
| Founded | 2012 | 2013 |
|---|
| Ownership | subsidiary of Smartsheet (itself PE-owned by Blackstone and Vista Equity Partners since 2025-01-22) | independent, VC-backed (Revaia, EQT Ventures, Blossom Capital, HighSage Ventures, Tenderloin Ventures) |
|---|
| Target market | Mid-market | Enterprise |
|---|
| Pricing model | quote-only tiers (Core/Basic, Premium, Enterprise) + add-ons (CDN bandwidth, video streaming, Content Automation, Insights Data Connector) | quote-only, monthly-active-user (MAU) based with six-month averaging |
|---|
| SSO | SAML | SAML, OIDC |
|---|
| Certifications | SOC 2 Type 2, ISO 27001 | ISO 27001, SOC 2 Type 2, TISAX, Cyber Essentials, HIPAA, Microsoft SSPA |
|---|
| Analyst coverage | Forrester Wave DAM Systems Q1 2026: Contender (Smartsheet/Brandfolder, per CMSWire) | Gartner MQ DAM Platforms 2025: Challenger · Forrester Wave DAM Systems Q1 2026: Contender |
|---|
| API style (overview) | REST | GraphQL |
|---|
| OpenAPI spec | Yes | No |
|---|
| Official MCP server | No | YesFrontify MCP Server, hosted, tool packs; beta |
|---|
| API base URL | https://brandfolder.com/api/v4 | https://{tenant}/graphql |
|---|
| API styles | REST | GraphQL |
|---|
| Authentication | API key | OAuth 2.0 client credentials, OAuth 2.0 authorization code, OAuth 2.0 PKCE, Personal token |
|---|
| Token lifetime | Not public (no expiry, rotation or refresh documented) | OAuth 1 week-3 months (configurable); single-use refresh; dev tokens up to 1 year |
|---|
| Rate limit | Not public; HTTP 429 per API key | 2,500 requests per 5-min rolling window; HTTP 429; query complexity cap |
|---|
| Pagination | page-based (page/per, default 100, max 3,000) | offset (page/limit, default 25, max 100); cursor for searchAssets |
|---|
| Webhooks (API) | API-managed, per Brandfolder, 3 asset events, up to 15 retries, no signature | API-managed (GraphQL), asset events only, HMAC-SHA256 signed, 10 retries |
|---|
| API spec | OpenAPI 3.0.3 (45 paths / 73 operations) | GraphQL SDL per member (no downloadable schema; assembled copy in specs/) |
|---|
| Official SDKs | Python, PHP (inactive), Panel UI SDK (official) | No server-side SDK; official JS/TS Finder, Authenticator, Brand SDK |
|---|